Plantains confuse people and I get it. I was confused too, when I was standing in a grocery store staring at a pile of green bananas-that-are-not-bananas wondering what I was supposed to do with them.

In this blog, we will talk about Amarillos vs Tostones, both are made from plantains but differ in ripeness, flavor, texture, and cooking method. And to know the difference between these two is important because many people get confused.

I’ve made both and I’ve messed up both. I burned a batch of tostones so bad my kitchen smelled terrible. Also I turned maduros into what I can only describe as plantain soup because I sliced them too thin and fried the oil too hot.

So, here’s the short version before we get into the details: amarillos are the sweet ones, tostones are the crispy savory ones. They are the same fruit but have totally different personalities. Once you get WHY that happens then it’s all about ripeness and you’ll never mix them up.

Let’s get into the difference between amarillos vs tostones.

Also Read:-

Hibachi Vs Stir Fry
Is Korean Food Good?
What is Ziti Sopranos?

What is Amarillos?

Amarillos are also called maduros, “maduro” it means ripe or mature in Spanish and they are made from plantains. It has yellow skin, black spots, sometimes almost fully black and that’s not a rotten plantain, but that’s a plantain that’s ready.

You peel them, slice diagonally or lengthwise, and fry. Once, sometimes low and slow over medium heat so the sugars have time to caramelize properly instead of burning on the outside.

The texture is soft, creamy almost. I’d go as far as calling it custard-like when done right. It’s the kind of bite that melts. And the flavor it gives is sweet, caramelized with a little savory in the background and it makes it taste almost like dessert.

I remember the first time I had good amarillos, at a small Cuban spot, I asked the server if there was sugar added. There wasn’t, that’s what a ripe plantain does when you fry it right.

What are Tostones?

Tostones are the opposite personality entirely. They are green plantains, firm, starchy, stubborn to peel.

They’re sliced into thick rounds, fried once, then SMASHED by using a tostonera, or a mug, a plate, the bottom of a pot or anything around and fried AGAIN. That double fry is non-negotiable. Skip it and you have boring fried plantain chunks. The second fry is where the magic happens.

It is crispy outside, slightly soft, and chewy. Savory, mild, a little nutty. 

In Colombia and Ecuador nobody calls them tostones. They’re patacones there. Same exact thing, different name, and I love that about plantain dishes because every region claims them differently.

Difference Between Amarillos Vs Tostones

At their core, amarillos vs tostones come from the same fruit. That’s the part that trips people up the most because they assume it’s two different plantain varieties or something but they are not. Where the plantain sits on the ripeness scale when you cook it determines EVERYTHING else like flavor, how it fries, what it pairs with, even how it looks on the plate. I like to think of it as the same person having a completely different mood. Below, I broke down every angle that matters about these two.

Plantain Ripeness

Amarillos need plantains that are yellow with black spots, or nearly all black. Tostones need plantains that are still green, firm, and dense.

This is the ONE decision point. Everything downstream it is all about sweetness, crunch, softness and it traces back to this single choice at the produce aisle.

Flavor

Amarillos taste sweet. It is genuinely sweet, caramelized, sometimes with a savory edge depending on how it’s fried.

Tostones taste savory, starchy and a little nutty. They don’t bring sweetness to the table at all; instead, they bring a blank canvas that soaks up any seasoning you throw at it.

Texture

It is soft, tender, almost creamy for amarillos. I’ve had some so soft I barely needed to chew.

Tostones though are crispy shell, softer center. It’s a textural contrast in a single bite, which is half the appeal.

Appearance

Amarillos come out golden brown, sometimes with darker caramelized edges that look almost burnt but taste incredible.

Tostones look pale gold, flattened, a little rustic. Some people say they resemble old Spanish “tostón” coins which is where the name might’ve come from.

Cooking Method

Amarillos are fried once. Sometimes baked or air-fried if you’re avoiding oil.

Tostones are fried, smashed, fried AGAIN and that’s the whole game right there.

Best Pairings

Amarillos go with rice, beans, picadillo, stews, pastelón, black beans because savory dishes that need something sweet to balance them out.

Tostones pair with dips like mayoketchup, garlic mojito sauce, guacamole, aji verde with stews, seafood, meats. They’re the appetizer/snack workhorse of the plantain world.

How to Make Amarillos? The Detailed Recipe

Making amarillos is one of the easier things you’ll cook this week. The trick isn’t technique, it’s patience with ripeness. If your plantain isn’t ripe enough, you’re not getting amarillos, you’re getting a weird chewy in-between thing. I learned that with an impatient batch that never softened. So, here’s the way you can make amarillos in the right way.

Ingredients:

• Ripe plantains (yellow with black spots, or nearly black)
• Oil for frying (canola works great — neutral flavor)
• A pinch of salt, optional
• A skillet or frying pan

Steps I would recommend to make amarillos:

1. Peel the plantains. They peel easier than green ones and it is satisfying.
2. Slice diagonally or lengthwise, whichever shape you prefer.
3. Heat oil in your skillet over medium heat.
4. Add the slices in a single layer. Don’t crowd the pan.
5. Fry slowly, letting the natural sugars caramelize. You want golden, not burnt.
6. Flip once the edges turn golden brown.
7. Fry the other side until caramelized too.
8. Remove, drain on a paper towel, and serve warm.

How to Make Tostones? The Detailed Recipe

Tostones take a bit more effort because there’s a rhythm to it, fry, smash, fry again, and if you rush any step it shows in the final crunch. I burned my FIRST attempt because I didn’t realize green plantains need more oil-temp attention. Oil is too hot and the outside chars before the inside cooks. Too cool and they turn greasy and sad. Once you nail the temperature though, this becomes meditative to make. So, let’s go and see.

Ingredients:

• Green, unripe plantains
• Oil for frying (canola preferred, neutral taste)
• Salt
• Garlic or adobo seasoning, optional
• A tostonera, or a mug/plate/pot bottom as a substitute

Steps I would recommend to make Tostones:

1. Peel the green plantains because this takes some muscle, they don’t come off easily.
2. Slice into thick rounds, about 1-1.5 inches.
3. Heat oil to roughly 375°F (190°C).
4. Fry the rounds until lightly golden. Not fully cooked, just a light color change.
5. Remove and let cool for a minute.
6. Smash each piece flat, about ¼ inch thick, using your tostonera or whatever’s handy.
7. Fry the flattened pieces again until crisp and golden.
8. Drain, salt immediately while hot, add garlic or adobo if using.
9. Serve with your favorite dip. Immediately because they lose their crunch fast.

Compare Amarillos Vs Tostones with Other Types

Plantains have a lot of preparations, and when you start looking, you realize amarillos and tostones aren’t the only characters. There’s maduros, plain plantains, mofongo, and general fried plantains that don’t fit neatly into either category. I think comparing these side-by-side helps clear up confusion than amarillos vs tostones breakdown alone.

Tostones Vs Maduros

Maduros and amarillos are the SAME dish, they have just different names depending on region. So tostones vs maduros is tostones vs amarillos in the different language, also it is about green vs ripe, savory vs sweet, crispy vs soft.

Tostones Vs Plantains

“Plantains” on their own just means the raw fruit, unripe or ripe, uncooked. Tostones are a specific preparation of the unripe version. So this comparison is apples to oranges… or plantains to plantains at different life stages.

Tostones Vs Mofongo

Mofongo takes tostones-style fried green plantains and MASHES them further, usually with garlic, pork cracklings, and broth, into a dense mound. Tostones stay separate and crispy. Mofongo is more of a main dish; tostones lean side or snack.

Amarillos Vs Tostones Vs Fried Plantains

“Fried plantains” is the category and both amarillos and tostones come under it. The difference is ripeness and technique. If someone says “I had fried plantains” without specifying, you don’t know if they had the sweet ones or the crispy ones. Ask them. 

Common Mistakes to Avoid in Amarillos and Tostones

I’ve made every mistake with both dishes, so let me save you with the mistakes. Most issues come down to ripeness selection, oil temperature, or impatience, rushing a process that rewards you for slowing down. Here’s what NOT to do.

• Using an underripe plantain for amarillos, it won’t caramelize properly, you’ll get a weird starchy sweetness instead of that deep golden flavor.
• Using an overripe or too-green plantain for tostones either too mushy to hold shape, or so hard you can’t smash it evenly.
• Frying oil too hot, it burns the outside before the inside cooks. 
• Frying oil too cool, plantains soak up excess oil and turn greasy instead of crisp.
• Skipping the double fry for tostones then you’ll get soft, floppy plantain instead of that signature crunch.
• Slicing amarillos too thin because they overcook and turn mushy fast.
• Not salting tostones after frying because the seasoning doesn’t stick as well once they cool.
• Overcrowding the pan, drops the oil temperature and everything cooks unevenly.
• Letting tostones sit too long before serving because they lose crispiness within minutes.

Conclusion

So there it is all about amarillos vs tostones, two completely different eating experiences from the same fruit. One’s sweet, soft and almost dessert-like. The other’s crispy, savory, and built for dipping.

In my opinion, I lean tostones more, mostly because I love anything crunchy with a good garlic dip. But when I want something that pairs perfectly with rice and beans or a hearty stew, amarillos is the best.

The opinion is simple: ripeness decides everything. Green plantain, crispy savory tostones. Ripe plantain, soft sweet amarillos. 

Try both. Actually taste the difference yourself instead of reading about it.

FAQs